Demographics is destiny. America's face is changing, but the real question is what will happen of our culture? The 2016 presidential race is, in many ways, a referendum on this changing face. Can we maintain unity in the midst of change? A common culture in the midst of diversity? This nation has absorbed cultural shock before, and we are stronger for it. Will this time be different?
A nation searches for a new identity
I don't think this diversification should be viewed as the country becoming less united. While it is easy to conclude that since we have less in common demographically, we are more distanced from each other, you have to consider some of our shared, underlying values as well. The article identifies this perfectly by saying "what unites America has always been greater than what divides us". And although the article expresses concern for our ability to maintain these common values, I don't think this is an issue. The country as a whole has experienced many hardships throughout its history and has always managed to maintain its unity. Even a Civil War couldn't keep it apart for too long. So, I think that this diversification is just another step in our history, and nothing to be worried about.
ReplyDeleteMatthew Stewart P.3
I don't think this article's author knew what it was talking about. It made the argument that our motto should be of one many. Sort of like saying we were once united but now are not. Or that we were once the same but are now different. America has always had immigrants and mixes of culture. Our nation was stated by colonists, British citizens. We have always been a mix of cultures. But we have also always been united as Americans by the principles of freedom. And although we have many differing opinions, ethnicities, and cultures that make us different it never divides us. We are always united and we are always Americans. We are truly of many different cultures and ethnicities one people united by freedom and our principles of government. Of many one.
ReplyDeleteKyle Wurtz
P. 5
Yes, our country was founded on change and diversity but at some point we need to draw the line. While our nation continues to grow we need to stay true to the basic founding principles which we were built on. Chief Justice John Roberts said it best, “The court today not only overlook’s our countries entire history and tradition but actively repudiates it, preferring to only live in the heady days of the here and now.” History has proven to us we cannot just look forward but we must always remember the past as well. If we continue this trend of falling away from our roots it will be the very thing that destroys us. However change is a good and purifying method to some degree. Yet it is up to us to decide what the changes should be. We need to restore our culture that respects diversity and rejects division.
ReplyDeleteJocelyn Ayers
P:3
I personally feel that times, culture, and race are not changing. Changing has always been the norm. After all, we are a Nation built upon immigration. We as Americans once started as a Europeans who traveled to this "New World" where a land of opportunity was available. Our Nation now still sticks by this. People seek a new, better, a more positive life and they strongly believe that the United States is the answer. With that being said, we see this "change" everyday so it shouldn't be something new. People are gonna continue to practice their customs and cultures and not everyone has to follow. Despite the differences in beliefs and culture that everyone has, we are still a strong standing Nation as One.
ReplyDeleteGregory James Pullon Jr.
Period 5
I do not necessarily agree with the author of this article. Yes, we as a nation, are becoming more and more diverse every day but this should not be viewed as an issue. If anything this should be perceived as something positive. Despite an extremely broad demographic in this country, we all are unified by our strong beliefs in our nation's core values. White, African-American, Christian, Muslim, Atheist, it doesn't matter what your race or religion may be, the desire to preserve freedom and liberty is at the core of us all. The diversification of this nation leads to new opportunities for those who were denied them in other countries, it prevents a single majority from gaining advantages over minority groups, and it's what makes our country so great. Embrace change and embrace differences.
ReplyDeleteNoah Rico
Period 5
I disagree with the author of the article. I don't think that the racial majority groups, religious affiliations, or adaptations to the definition of marriage are proof of a dissembling nation. I just think that all these occurrences show a definite evolution of the American people. I don't think the Framers or any of the first Americans would imagine the things we can do now but I don't think they would believe that we have become a disaggregated nation either. I believe that with all of these changes, it just shows that we are a country that allows for each person's differences and with accepting these differences we are in our own way, united. I think because we are so grounded in such defining principles, we would shift in this direction eventually
ReplyDeleteLyndsey Chu P2
Change happens around us constantly, and if us as Americans cannot adapt to a new society that integrates many races, religions, and opposing views then we will soon implode. This nation is rapidly transforming from a single majority dominated country, to a diverse and all encompassing one. With more cultures incorporated, unification may seem difficult but as the author states, "[W]hat unites America has always been greater than what divides us". I believe that we should start to embrace each other's uniqueness in culture and remain open minded about the future of our country. We have handled immigration coming into our country before, we can surely do it again.
ReplyDelete-Madison Rhind p. 3
When I hear the words, "out of many, one" I see out nation as a whole living in harmony. Now that is to say there will be differences because we are such a diverse nation built on immigration and cultural diversity. Today we see cultural diversity more than ever, and it goes beyond race now into many other ares subject to debate. Whether is divides us or brings some closer together we should realize we are built on freedom and opportunity. From that we will always be one from the many people that bring us together and make us the nation we are.
ReplyDeleteIn my eyes, the country being more and more demographically diverse isn't a bad change at all. The author says that since we are becoming more diversified therefore that means that our country is straying from its original motto, translated from Latin is "out of one, many". Which is entirely false, I believe the motto means out of our entire nation as a whole (the one) comes many different people, not one clone of a person being duplicated many times over again so that our country is seen as "unified". Unification of the people isn't believeing in one specific thing, it's the people themselves blending together as a whole and being able to overcome things like skin color and religion. A couple things he did say that were correct were that older republicans, or older white citizens, see that the diversification is against the motto of the country while the younger more liberal population see the change and embrace it with open arms. I believe or hope that the country is going to go back to being a melting pot of all different cultures to where all race, religions, and nationalities are accepted equally. It may be a stretch, but our country as a whole has typically been welcoming to change, and our younger population is going to lead our country in the nearer than many think, future. With a more liberal viewpoint, the demographic change will be embraced in full for what it is, as the country strays more and more from one race/ religious group being a majority the country will be able to fluidly make a jump in the right direction of embracing the change as well as the differences of the influx of new beliefs and ethnicities into our most beloved nation.
ReplyDelete- Will Montgomery P.2
This article seems to present the growing diversity and variation in America as a growing problem. That it will cause our downfall in the spreading of ideas too thin, with too many clashes of personality and culture in order to possibly succeed or stay united. But the separation of ideals, the slowness of the process, and the allowance of such variability and diversity is what the United States was framed around, the separation of powers, the super majority votes, everything was contributed to slowing things down and allowing a difference in ideas to thrive! Not to die. I believe the increasing diversity can do great things, if everyone embraces the idea of being an American and standing for America as a whole, we can be stronger than ever before and more unified as well. If we let old prejudices overwhelm our patriotism and nationalism, then the ever growing variation will be our demise.
ReplyDeleteHunter Mittelstaedt
Period 3
I can understand why for some people it's weird to think about whites not being the dominant race in the country. For me and almost all of us, we are surrounded by diversity. When we're sitting in class and look to the left and right of us we see different cultures, races, and religions. When you (Mr. Cavanaugh) asked how many of us had immigrant parents, more than half the class raised their hands. Yes, this country has dramatically changed demographically. I think the only thing stopping us from being united are groups of people who believe that everyone around them needs to believe what they believe. When concerning religion for example, I can be friends with an atheist and still retain my Christian values. Although this friendship may not be united by religion, its united by our desire to care for one another and our ability to have a common-place conversation. Just like our country, even with its diverse nature, we should all be united by the same desire to make the country a better, safer place for ALL. Not for Mexicans, or blacks, or arabs, or whites, but for ALL.
ReplyDelete-Jumana Roufail, Period 2
In theory, diversity is welcomed whether it be in schools or in our ideas. However, with diversity comes different opinions and ideas that can often clash. We have made it a point to focus on our differences and not the underlying forces that unite us. It seems that we have come under this false belief that it is impossible to be amicable with one another if we have differing opinions. That all of a sudden compromise between Democrats and Republicans is impossible because if we compromise on one of our own beliefs we are on the "losing" side which is completely false. Concerning race, I think that we can often stereotype an entire race without knowing the individual and what he or she believes which can cause division. We can be united despite our differences, It is just a matter of being willing to accept that not everyone will look the same or think the same as one another.
ReplyDelete-natalie tang
p. 3
E Unum Pluribus is definitely true. We are out of one, many. It is a fact that the numbers are changing and more people are furthering their education. However, American shouldn't feel threatened because America's culture is the land of many. I believe it is possible to maintain unity in the midst of change, but it all depends on the willingness of everyone involved. As a country we shouldn't have to decide to wipe away our individual cultures for the American culture or to keep our individual culture and tune out the American culture. We should see the benefit in keeping both and blending them together. Our differences make us united. I believe that there is a common culture in the midst of diversity. It is constantly unrecognized because of how general we make it and easily we mix it among our own cultures. There shouldn't be a worry of America becoming more diverse and the culture shifting. We call ourselves the land of the free. Where their is Freedom their are choices. These choices have an unending range that inevitably creates diversity.
ReplyDeleteAlyssa Hill
Period 2
American culture will become increasingly different as minorities will feel less pressure to conform to the non-existent majority. As an individualist nation, unity is not an easy thing. No two people can completely agree on anything, so it makes sense why some people are so hesitant to change. Despite this a majority of the population will always be united in desiring the best for themselves, their families, their homes, and their country. It is patriotism that bonds the American people under a common culture. This is made apparent in us abiding by similar societal norms and sharing a common individualistic goal at success. Regardless of time and space, America has always been able to overcome its differences and I believe this time will be no different. It was just fifty years ago that interracial marriage was upheld in federal court. It just goes to shows that some things never change, given enough time people will get over the same-sex marriage ruling and then find something new to protest about. Robert Snyder P. 2
ReplyDeletePersonally , I don't agree with the view on this article. America has always been based on diversity and the idea of change. We have always been more of a open minded country as we have been evolving and been more accepting of people's differences. I don't think this is an issue and it should be seen as a beautiful thing that America is accepting of others.
ReplyDeleteLuz Cabada Period 2
It's hard to predict the future. For one, the Roman empire was essentially destroyed by diversity. In a place with to many different opinions, some are bound to clash. To hate what we don't truly understand is a natural human trait. How many of those who hate Muslim's truly understand the message of Islam? How many of those who hate white people know that every individual is different? or truly seek to understand their point of view? There is still friction between the black and white communities because racism and segregation were never really dealt with. Politically slaves were free, but how about socially? Politically segregation was outlawed, but socially did both sides come to terms? The problem in America (and the reason why it is hard to foresee us coming together as one people) is that politically we can deal and accept each other differences, but socially we can never. E Unum Pluribus translates to "out of many, one". However out of many we instead ended up with many factions/political parties (something George Washington wished to never happen). Why as people do we seek to separate ourselves? Differences of opinion are normal and help us reach a better decision, yet we label each other and then pit ourselves against each other. Unity comes through friction, it is when groups are made. America itself will probably always be divided into different groups and not a melting pot as people like to claim we are. However when America as a whole is pit against an obstacle, that is when we come together. Unity will come and unity will fade. Truly we are no different from other countries, they are divided too on the inside (whether its readily seen or carefully hidden). The reason why it is so prominent to us is because our differences are more pronounced and vocalized.
ReplyDeleteMichael Diamreyan p. 5
DeleteI think the solution to the problems you highlight are to be found in greater economic equality and education. Racism is fueled by stereotypes, and low socio-economic status continues to perpetuate the stereotypes. People respect wealth and education. They are the great equalizer.
DeleteI disagree with the author of this article. I could understand that some of us think whites not being the dominant race in the country is weird, but our country is built on and surrounded by diversity. Us being diverse should never be an issue here but looked at as a positive statement. With all these changes going on it gives us a chance to embrace on new ideas and cultures. If we keep moving in this direction as well as keeping the freedoms and liberties of everyone, we could all be in some way, united. The diversity allows opportunities to those of different races who may have been denied them in other countries.
ReplyDeleteClay Reyes p. 2
Honestly I understand where the author is coming from. Change is scary, and it seems like there is too much going on. However how will a nation ever improve if it doesn't change and adapt to our citizens' needs and wants. What I do love about America is the passion that people display, we have passed so many laws and actions merely because there were enough people invested into that cause at the same time. It's similar to what we talked about today in class. America used to be a melting pot, and sure 100 years ago it was necessary to change to fit in. But now as the generations grow older, people are more accepting of other cultures and preferences. America has turned into a salad bowl, and you know what people are okay with that. Diversity is important to grow and spread or share ideas and I truly believe that this country will thrive off of it. As long as people continue to embrace it.
ReplyDeleteLauren Hartogh P. 3
These everyday diversities should be taken in as a positive tone and not a bad one. I believe that we are stronger with them than without them because without them we wouldn't have the environment that we have today. These same people are the ones who are advancing our everyday lives. For example in the article it says
ReplyDelete" 1 out of 3 Americans have completed college" and these numbers will keep rising as the years go by. With these result increasing by the year we should be proud and not discouraged. Overall I believe that we should keep recognizing these diversifications as a way to better out community/government.
Mirna Munoz Period 5
DeleteI think that it is a good thing that America is becoming more diverse. There is no one majority that is in charge and so no minority can be overlooked or oppressed. This diversification is an also a gradual push toward acceptance of different religions, cultures, ethnicities, etc. The author of the article seemed to fear that we were straying away from our motto of “out of many one” but I think we are embracing it now more than ever. We share the American belief of freedom for all and as the article said we live in a nation where “new dimensions of freedom become apparent to new generations”. If we are more accepting of others we are more united as there is less internal conflict.
ReplyDeleteAndrea Campos Period 5
I agree with you, this is the 21st and since we, as a society and humans, have evolved into ideas and have become better educated, there should be non of the fear of division. And as the "new generation" has anyone ever really thought how this will effect future generations. There shouldn't be war or conflicts in order to be able to band together, why is there a necessity for it? If this country was really founded under the impression of "Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness", why allow such unconstitutional laws to be passed. Will this really mark the end of the United States of America? Why don't we as a society and humans just accept this diversity it will lead us to a better tomorrow than a rotten future.
DeleteAlexia Tejeda period 3
I don't think the increase in diversification is a bad thing. I think the issue lies in the fact that certain areas in the United States are primarily one ethnic group, as we saw on the map in class. Here in Rancho there are a lot of ethnic groups, but I don't feel less American or less similar to my peers because of it. But I think it will be extremely difficult for people to adjust to the increase in diversification simply because of the large masses of immigrants coming. The white population will find it especially hard because they are shifting from a majority group to a minority group, signaling a loss of power, which will no doubt be hard to accept. However, I think we will be able to maintain unity. As the article states "what unites America has always been the greater than what divides us," and we have overcome much greater obstacles than diversification.
ReplyDeleteTiffany Lu P.2
i wasn't very sold on the way this was written as far as the author goes but the big issue here is that i think diversification is something positive we should embrace and continue to let happen. i think we should remain this way to let people get opportunities and not have to worry whether or not they'll be judged by the color of their skin or how they look. diversification will also allow our nation to unify even more because it would help those who may think one race is superior that in fact that isn't the case at all and we in fact are one big nation and that were all united,
ReplyDeleteEthan Cisneros
Period 5
I agree with the author that our diversification is dividing America, but only because people are letting it. I think that America should step up and start accepting our diversity, as it can make it stronger as a society. There are people now like Trump who are choosing not to see people as people, but instead by there differences in a judgemental way. The common thought nowadays is "oh they're different than the average American and because of that I'm better than them". If we accept our differences we can all learn many things as our nation has done so in the past. Our nation is built on diversity, and that is what made us one of the strongest nations in the world. I think it is great that diversity in America is increasing and I hope we can all learn to accept it so we can come together and teach each other and become more well rounded people because of it.
ReplyDeleteAshley Quintana
P.3
This article seems to portray different ideas as a problem for our country, But in reality it is the opposite. Madison's theory for the Republic all depends on many different factions competing to implement their ideas into the Government. What the author is proposing is in fact a one faction government. What's ironic is that this idea of only one faction had been tested prior to the formation of the constitution, in state governments. Some states prior to the Revolution did allow only White Christian landowning males to vote, so if the founding fathers really felt that our sense of unity as a country would be threatened by what the author describes "different religions,races, ideas", then why would they leave the idea that state constitutions practiced and instead decide to give freedom of religion and speech?
ReplyDeleteOmar Moiz P.2
Madison's theory is definitely being put to the test!
DeleteI do understand where the author is coming from as we have never seen such a demographic change in our nation but this shouldn't have a negative connotation. Regardless of this change, we are still united under the same concept of freedom. Our country was built on diversity and throughout the years we have still stayed united under this fundamental belief. We continue to be more accepting of different beliefs and cultures. The different religions and ethnicity's make our nation stronger. Although we do need to keep our roots in mind, this diversity is necessary for us to keep moving forward. The only thing stopping that is the people who refuse to be accepting of others' beliefs and opinions. Overall, this change and increasing diversity is beneficial to our growing nation.
ReplyDeleteMatthew Johnson-P.2
I believe this increasing trend towards ethnic diversity is a great thing. The fact that we are moving towards an america without one dominant ethic group is exciting because it is so unprecedented. Of course there will be growing pains throughout the process and we are feeling many of them now. I just feel as though we will come out of it much stronger a more united than before. Because when we spend so much time looking at what separates us from others we will all realize that we share a central commonality. We are all Americans and we are all here to enjoy life and better it for future generations.
ReplyDeleteChandler Sallaberria
P. 3
DeleteAlthough the author's views toward change seem to be relatively negative, I feel as though change is not only a positive thing, but necessary. Americans today all come from different backgrounds and cultures, but we all share a common bond, the pride that comes with being an American. Many immigrants are escaping horrible poverty-stricken conditions in their homes, persecution for their religion, censorship, etc, and so when they come to America they are thankful for their new life and freedoms. Immigrants, while still maintaining pride for their home country, embrace the "American ideals" of freedom, patriotism, etc, and this is what ultimately bonds all Americans together. The introduction of new cultures, languages, and ethnicities strengthen the idea of what America is: a land of opportunity and diversity, a land where anyone from any country can come and succeed if they worked hard enough for it. The diversification of our country strengthens that belief and our country overall and we should ultimately embrace change with open arms.
ReplyDeleteSharen Moniqca period 2
I do see the where the author wants to say and it is true that we are becoming more and more diverse as the year pass by but that doesn't mean we are dividing ourselves. Yes everyone is different but that isn't a bad thing we don't all have to value the same things but even though we don't we still share the same values of liberty and in bad times we stand together no matter your race or religion. We are becoming more accepting of different people and that's good for unification because we aren't excluding people. This shows that we aren't separation ourselves but instead we are more likely to unite.
ReplyDeleteI believe the author's tone was negative as he wrote about how the people that make up the United States are continuously becoming more diverse. I personally believe that diversity is something that makes the U.S better. As a bi-cultural student, I see diversity as something that makes our community better by always presenting different ideas, ideals, religions, and even food. This diversity is always refreshing and renewing. However, this doesn't mean that diversity doesn't come with its problems; we are seeing some of it now. I still believe that even though there are problems, this diversity will only bring us closer as a nation once we truly understand how diversity can be a great and positive impact.
ReplyDeleteI do not agree with this author. I mean, what America is that we're diverse. However, we are brought together by our own beliefs doesn't matter if you are white, brown, black, Muslim, Christian etc. Our diversity helps everyone in their one way succeed in life. Our diversity prevents a majority dominating a minority. People come to the US because of the American dream. They come for a new better life and a next chance. Despite our differences we are what makes up the United States... We are different.
ReplyDeleteEthan Aurangzeb
Period 2
It is true that throughout time America has changed drastically from its founding days, but this is not necessarily a bad thing. This newfound diversity has brought along more cultural awareness and education on different types of people. If America were to remain the same and not grow in diversity there would be no change, meaning no progress. Immigrants bring along their different beliefs and cultures and strengthen our country. I believe instead of finding difference among different groups of people we should encourage these differences and be more open minded to the changing face of America.
ReplyDeleteSaketh Sadhu
Period 3
I do not agree that our differences are dividing us. Though within the past couple of year it may seem like it, I think the bigger picture shows otherwise. For example, interracial couples are seen as no big deal for most Americans today but only a few decades ago you would most likely get disowned by your family. Differences don't need to divide people, it can unite people. I think embracing diversity allows us to become more compassionate which in turn benefits us. Change can be good, it just depends on what perspective you look at it from.
ReplyDeleteRebecca Platero P.2
I am unsure of whether or not we will be able to absorb the cultural shock. By all means, we should try, but not everyone is on the same page. As the article said, some like that the country is progressing, and some are uneasy with it. Truth of the matter is even though we are a nation made of people from all walks of life, ironically, things like race, religion, sexual orientation, and politics can still divide us in 2017 (doesn't apply to all Americans only some). However, if we do not learn how to agree to disagree, America is in deep trouble. We need to learn to agree to disagree now more than ever. With all this national upset and protest going around two weeks after the inauguration, imagine what will come of the social climate in one term. I'm not saying we all have to be okay with each other, we just have to learn to accept what happens and coexist because at times that will be the only option we have left to do. Some will be unhappy with change because America IS evolving and is beginning to look more socially liberal. However, we are at the point of no return and we have no choice but to keep moving forward with these mass social movements. The reason we are now of one, many, is the American people used social progression as a catalyst not to turn back, to move forward. We are not meant to regress, because we have to become diverse to learn and grow. We won't learn and grow if we're all the same, we'll learn to love the diversity if we're all different. Change will take place whether we like it or not, but we have to figure out a way to coexist.
ReplyDeleteKyla Wheeler, p. 2
:)
DeleteYes I agree that we should use what our country was founded on as a basis of our basic beliefs, but only to a certain extent. Times have changed so many of the, what we call now, "old fashioned" values that were once so important to the founders of the US, do not work in our society today. With many different religions, races, and cultures abiding in America in present day, we should find a happy median that suits all when it comes to equality. I disagree that the "many" in this country make it harder for us to unite. The "many" is what makes up the unique and blended American culture. Yes, you can view it as everyone picking and choosing parts of their culture to still practice, but doesn't that make us have our own identities while still being united as the fact of being American? At the end of the day, under everyone's skin, we are the same: united by the freedom we are granted by living in this country.
ReplyDeleteThis increasing diversification will allow all Americans to be treated fairly and will allow the voices of all Americans to be heard. I can understand why certain privileged groups may feel that this diversification is hostile; privileged groups understand that they will not have the overwhelming majority of the population and will therefore see this change as harmful to them because it will remove their power. White, Protestant, straight men with non-radical political views have been the majority of the population since our nations inception and have always held the power. This allowed for the marginalization of anyone that did not fit all of the aforementioned groups. However, with increasing diversification of the US, this tyranny of the majority will not be able to continue, and all types of Americans will be heard. This is a refreshing concept to me, especially as someone who belongs to several of these marginalized groups. I think that this diversification is clearly a positive thing and should be seen as such- those who are intimidated by it likely have some power to loose from it.
ReplyDeleteMadeline Casolari
P.3
America is a wonderful place. And it is also true that we have trained drastically from when the 13 colonies were first established. But if we did not have these changes we would not be the diverse country that we are now. We have so many religions, races, ethnicities, and customs that make America the wonderful diverse country that it is. And America will keep changing as the world gets older, more people come to America, and as people are brought into our world.
ReplyDeleteAbeegail Meyer p.3
As humans, we have to accept that change is inevitable. I agree with some of my peers that the differences that we identify with should not be the cause of the tension among generations, ethnicity, etc. Instead, the real cause of the predicament is the mere fact that some are afraid of this change. The more society feels confined by old expectations, the more they'd want to rebel against it, because especially now, it's just how us millennials are. The things that make us different are what is being praised. With all due respect to those who oppose, society is evolving with or without them. Now that they are becoming a minority group, I think there really isn't much else that they could do about it. Also, it's fair game, since technically, there will probably be no majority in the direct future. I'm not saying that they have to accept all these changes in our modern-day culture, but I am a firm believer that we should all respect each other's differences. In doing so, hopefully, could unite our nation.
ReplyDelete(Charlize Villamin-De Leon, Period 2)
After reading the article, I don't agree with the author's central argument. It's hard to predict the future of a nation. It's difficult to know whether or not changes will be beneficial or harmful to our country. However, with the state of the nation at the moment and everything that is happening with the ban on the 7 nations, I think that it's critical that the nation needs to accept diversity. Diversity is what made the United States the nation it is today. In our school and even in our classes, there's a diverse group of students who come from different backgrounds, both race and religion. From my view, I think that the country needs to accept that we all are different. We all have different ethnicities and religions and outlooks on the new marriage laws. We each have our own opinions and identities. Our nation's motto translates to "Out of many, one". Why can't we apply our motto now? Why do we need to divide ourselves from each other? Even if we did, what benefits would come out of that? Our motto wouldn't have meaning if we started to divide ourselves because of our ethnicities, religion, orientation, opinions, etc. Change is inevitable, it just depends how the rest of the country is going to handle it.
ReplyDelete*Kennedy Madrid P.5
Delete*I also deleted my original comment. I wanted to say a little more and expand on what I was saying.
I couldn't help but notice the slight negative tone the author has regarding the cultural progress our country is making. If anything, it should be seen as a positive change. With the increase in diversity, no one group can be singled out and have to face discrimination from the rest whether it be in terms of race, religion, or sexuality. I do understand where they are coming from in regards to this diversity also splitting up the nation and not allowing us to find a common cause to unite. Our different mindsets and opinions contribute to this immensely for example, political views. I have observed too much conflict with people of different political views in which neither tries to understand the other, resulting in a futile debate (more like argument). We should be trying harder to unify, especially now as we get into the Trump administration. We cannot keep letting our diverse ways of thinking cloud out the importance of sticking together as a nation and embracing the new aspects and cultures coming into our country.
ReplyDeleteLitzulli Figueroa
per. 5
I think that the argument that our country should be run on the basis of culture that it was started upon is absurd. When our country was founded 200 years ago, social norms and the culture of the entire country was obscenely different to that of today. This country was meant to be a country of dreams, where people could come and make their life into whatever they want it to be, and for that t happen change needs to occur. We have increased diversification racially and socially and it is an amazing thing. This means that groups who were once a tiny minority can have their voices heard and take part in shaping the direction of this country. As time goes on social norms change and clinging to the past is going to cause set backs to the people of the country. This diversification can eventually make us more unified than ever before, in my opinion, because final everyone can be heard.
ReplyDeleteClaire Williams
p. 3
I definitely see the differences in opinion described in the article. I don't exactly think that the demographic and social changes are surprising or new, but I think that some people are startled or overwhelmed by an increasingly adaptive society. I also think that the perceived divide in beliefs in a generational one. And while I may perceive some of these opinions and actions as motivated by a fear of progress, I'm sure that those who hold these opinions would say that they are motivated by an appreciation for tradition. I would argue that what most divides us is also what most unites us as a nation; our devotion to expressing individual beliefs and ideologically rejecting the other side to those beliefs. So really we're not so different. I think we just need to learn to embrace change as progress and not some scary attack on tradition.
ReplyDeleteJulia Hernandez P.3
I do not agree with the author because he stated how cultural diversity has “eroded those pillars of American identity”. It appears that he imagines a true American to be white and Protestant, but it’s not fair to think that some people are less American than others solely based on race, the color of their skin, or religion. Change is scary, and I agree with that, and I think that is why people are seeing diversity as a bad thing. Culture and ethnicities are changing really quickly, and it’s intimidating, even for me. But I see this as a good thing, and it could benefit us. If more people see it as a mixing of ideas and principles that can make us stronger, then we will move forward as country together.
ReplyDelete-Tiffany Inouye P.3
Personally, I don't believe that these demographic changes are necessarily a bad thing. Having such a diverse group of people that are represented in this country is beneficial to both citizens of this country and to the human race in general because exposure to all these different cultures and backgrounds gives us the opportunity to learn from each other. Other countries like Japan don't really get to experience this wide variety of people like we do. "Out of one, many" and "out of many, one" are both appropriate phrases that define this country because while we all have differences that should be acknowledged and celebrated, we are all united through this experience of truly being part of an ever-changing American culture.
ReplyDeleteCassidy Wagner
Period 2
I somewhat do not agree with the author of this article. I believe that the difference in race, religion, and culture is what shapes and makes America. It is true that we are being more diverse but can this be a bad thing? I believe that the new ideas and culture merely broaden the current American culture. The term "out of one, many" is true. We are "many" but we are still part of one. This means that we are built on differences but we are still a unified nation. As long as people respect differences our nation should be able to continue to expand and broaden the American culture.
ReplyDeleteChristopher Tong
Period 5
I believe this article can't speak for the entire country when it says that our differences are driving us apart. Like you said in class, we are in a bubble here in Rancho, we're not really determining the differences of each other as being detrimental to our society. I believe that there are many other bubbles like these in America, enough to call it a form of unity. I know growing up in Rancho might give me some sort of bias, but I just don't think that a large majority of people think to themselves that the diversity in the country is going to hurt them in some way. Honestly, as long as we try to continue our daily lives, I see no issue with diversity, it is a natural healer and will eventually rid of the issues in society.
ReplyDeleteRyan Cain Per. 3
The beauty of living in a country like this is that the people have the freedom to pursue their liberties and celebrate their cultures, in which I only believe adds to America as a whole by educating us all further on something foreign. Times are changing, and while the article points out the Republican "Coalition of Restoration", I fail to see how increasing minority populations and sexual preferences could be considered just a "here and now". Rather, they are evidence of an increasingly tolerant nation, and aware that progression is key. What only divides us is the desperate need to hold onto the past and the perpetuation of tired ideologies, that thankfully, many of us are aware America has outgrown. Embracing our diversity is what continues to make our nation stronger.
ReplyDeleteP.5
DeleteI believe that this change in America's demographic, along with the inevitable introduction of ideals, is not a alone enough to separate America and its people. Despite the increasing diversification of America, I believe the ideals that have held America together through economic shocks, war, and now cultural change still hold their place in every American citizens values. American's still believe in working hard to get to the top, still have pride for this nation, and continue to see this land as the land of the free where personal differences do not dull the love one has for the US. I believe the concerns the author addresses are concerns for people who doubt the patriotism of the American people and fear the being an American citizen alone is not enough to hold the people tight enough together and continue American ideals. However, these concerns have proven throughout American history to be in vain in that as America has become more colorful, Americans have widely continued to share common ideals. This trend does not foreshadow something bad to come, but is just an effect of America's acceptance of people of all cultural backgrounds.
ReplyDeleteEmmanuel Mintah P. 3
I don’t particularly agree with the authors point in the article, I believe the mass increase of diversity in America is what makes up American culture in a beneficial way, the introduction of change away from majority. It’s a projection of growth and stability that unites the country as a whole. The culture and demographic change does not divide or simply erode the “American way”, but simply creates a new culture with its own roots, not the same as our predecessors. That with trial and error, that cultural, demographic, and social change has been shaped throughout history and defined as American culture. To erode the American identity would simply be incorrect, over several generations the identity is altered to accommodate, it’s a continuous process of change that has the potential to make us stronger.
ReplyDeleteSabrina Amador P.3
This article sounded weird to me. It was as if the author was assigned to write an unbiased article about the ever changing diversity in America, yet he made it come off as passive aggressive. Also, he made it sound like gay people just became a thing like 10 years ago lmao. The only way we can stay unified is if people embrace diversity and realize that everyone is different and we all share different experiences. The term 'culture shock' is so funny to me because it sounds like a boring man coming across a Mariah Carey song (preferably Loverboy or After Tongiht) and it leaving him shook. I think if people just embraced diversity their wouldn't need to be any shock value. I don't think this country will ever be totally unified but I do believe, over time, people do change and hopefully our country becomes stronger and more accepting.
ReplyDeleteRyan Van Balen P.5
There has also always been two sides in debates involving diversity. There is one side that is fighting for equality and just want to be treated like humans, and the other, that tends to be irredeemably awful. People need to put their differences aside and work together because if someone is denying others of freedom, what does this country even stand for?
DeleteRyan Van Balen
I just have one thing to say: E PLURIBUS UNUM!
ReplyDeleteWe need to reinvigorate our national motto moreso now than ever before. Our motto should turn into a national movement. Maybe even a new political party; call it the EPU. It can start as a new club on this campus, and then spread regionally. EPU-tiful. I know our original motto refers to many states coming together to form one union, but that is so 18th century. The motto can be redefined for the 21st century to refer to many different people/cultures coming together to form one, united people committed to basic human values.
Where can I sign up?
DeleteYoo Mr. Cavanaugh, we might have to rename the club *-*
Delete-Sebastian Arceo
*My previous entry got accidentally deleted, but here's a simplified version of what I wrote:
DeleteThe author and I share the same sentiment in regards to the unification of the inestimable diversity of America: HARD. Every day, I beat myself up thinking about how ONE government is expected to accommodate the infinitely diversified interests of the American people. I honestly feel bad for Trump as I put myself in his shoes. I can't imagine trying to lead a country and getting scrutinized for every move I make. Every time he whispers a word, a thousand more people join a protest. Trying to make decisions in a country that is in "Democrat vs Republican", "Us Versus Them", smash-mouth mode makes me want to run into my bed and pull the blankets over. Today, the maps showing the populations densities of each ethnicity throughout the U.S expressed to me that minorities are not as assimilated as we BELIEVE they are. This is only one of the many social chasms America faces. Mix in the political and economical differences, and we have a divided, "United", States of America. So far this entry seems pessimistic, but I believe that a common struggle (Hopefully not another civil war), will bring the "many" together. Not until we can ask ourselves, "Why are we even arguing?" and realize that everyone has, or SHOULD have, the mutual interest of the greater good, will America unite. E Unum Pluribus.
Sebastian Arceo
P-5
As diversification in America increases, the definition of what it means to be "American" simply expands once more. While this may result in some apprehension in white Americans, who currently make up the majority racial group, increasing diversity should not cause these sorts of fears. The author of the article describes these differences as "fault lines," which is a false statement that perpetuates the fear in diversification, as if these differences provide for a irreconcilable rift between our society. This is not the case. Today, what it means to be American is starkly different to what it used to, and encompasses values and traits from all different racial, social, and religious groups. In no way does this mean that we cannot maintain unity in the midst of this change, because despite it, we still share common aspects of the American culture and will continue to do so. Retention of our own respective identities, while taking in influence from American culture only serves to display our nation as one that stands together strong as well as diverse. I firmly believe that this culture shock will allow us to be more unified than ever, because it paves the way for a more open-minded and accepting America.
ReplyDeleteGianna Apoderado P. 5
The author of the article portrays the diversification of the United States as a problem. I disagree as I believe that a more diverse country would prosper. This article reflects the ongoing fear of change that are in the majority groups, the fear of losing their position as the "majority". These groups need to realize that they can hinder this change but they can not stop it from happening.
ReplyDelete- Gursimran Bains (Period 3)
I honestly believe that change is one of the best things that could happen to America. It provides more exposure to different ideas and different cultures, and with that increased exposure, people could become more accepting and united. America is supposed to be this huge melting pot where all people are accepted, and all liberties are valued. I don't think that even with such an unprecedented change in the makeup of the American population that we will be separated. The author of this article made change seem dangerous and threatening to American ideals, but one of the greatest American ideals is the idea that all people are welcome and have freedom to practice whatever religion they want, love whoever they want, and be whoever they want in this country. This progression is what we need to further improve America's tolerance for people that are "different".
ReplyDeleteAlysa Quijada
Deletep.2
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteOur nation is changing whether we like it or not. The glorious thing about this country is that we have the freedom to choose to live whoever we would like. We have the ability to worship who we would like, marry our same sex even different races. This alone should be proof enough how different thing have changed since the last 50-60 years. Though this may not be 100% accepted throughout this nation, I believe that this facade we have is better than showing the world how truly divided we are. Inequality will forever be present but hopefully it won't always be the grey elephant in the room. Furthermore, it's sad to say that we put so much emphasis on what makes us different rather than encouraging our diversity and praising our similarities. We shouldn't wait for some act of war to unity us. And America is finally starting to realize that; slowly but surely.
ReplyDeleteSorry.
DeleteDorian Cardoza Per. 5
I think that different generations respond to change in their own ways. And that people who find the concept of same-sex marriage, or the increase of minorities in schools or the rise of immigrants a downside aren't looking at the "land of opportunity "ideology our nation was founded on. I do believe, no matter what minority rises or what ever else instances cause a culture shock that America will still maintain a slight unity in the face of change. The fact is we all came here for a better life and we brought our cultures with us to add to the salad bowl that is these 50 states. And at the end of the day, the land is what brings us together.Also, we have a common culture because of diversity. If you ever ask a non-American what their idea of "American-Culture" is it will be a mix different aspects of cultures that have molded into one.
ReplyDelete- Chloe' Kasozi p,5
The author has a big misconception on what they think unifies a nation. They believe that we need to believe and do the same thing which means less diversity. I think that it's just foolish for them to think this way when in reality the more diverse we get, the better we have become. The more cultures means more ideas and people with different thoughts and beliefs that help this nation grow. Diversity, not just by race, makes this nation essentially free due to the fact that we come to the US knowing we can be our culture or believe what we believe without persecution. In a sense this would make a better and happier society of Americans knowing that know one is judging the real you.
ReplyDelete- Justin Andal Per. 3
I honestly do not like the negative perspective on America's increasing diversity that the article gave. I feel that the rising numbers of different races and religions plays a beneficial impact on the United States, culturally. Having a community of so many different people is what makes us learn new ideas and traditions to incorporate into our own lives. If everyone is all alike and has the same things in common, I don't see us growing as a whole. Regarding such a rapid change, I imagine it would be less strenuous to accept and work with it rather than be worried about how it's different from what America used to be.
ReplyDeleteLindsay Gonzalez Period 2
After reading this article, I noticed how the authors main point is that every individual is melting to unify as "one." I disagree with this claim because there are many present day examples that we do not just blend. The countless protests that occur are proof that we the people disagree with each other and fight for our personal beliefs. America is known to be the city of immigrants and you cannot blend different cultures and values into one. If one group is feeling oppressed, they will not just accept their suffering because they conform as "one."
ReplyDeleteAmerica is, on the other hand, learning how to embrace different ideology, cultures, and traditions. This is not a tranquil or rapid process and in some cases we are learning the hard way. Our society can never be labeled under one category simply because it is too diverse.
Maya Domozetska
P.3
Having diversity in our country would not break our unity because being diverse would only make us stronger as a nation and it would bring more culture to share and spread which has always been happening in America. Changing has always been normal and refreshing in our country because it brings new ideas and creations. Despite our differences (race/ religion/ gender/ age), we always have this common principal of “liberty” that ties us all in together. The author should not be looking at diversity in such a negative perspective because our nation was founded by immigrants and was meant to be diverse at some point in time to create our American culture which will not tear us apart but make us stronger as a whole.
ReplyDeleteAmanda Lor Period 5
America is becoming more and more diverse… so what? The author in the article seems to resent the idea of diversity however it should not be seen as an issue. Change is something that is constant, it happens to everyone. Even before the United States formed, change had to take place in order to be where we are now as a nation. The United States should embrace diversity rather than to fear it. In the article the author believes that the U.S. is “out of one, many” but even though we have different cultures, beliefs, religion, etc, it doesn’t change the fact that people migrated to America for a better life and opportunity which makes us “out of many, one”. I believe that if we maintain unity in midst of change we will prevail because in the past it has been prove that unity is what kept us strong.
ReplyDeleteJosette Yasay Period:2
I do not think the increasing diversity of the country is something that divides Americans. What divides Americans are people who are not used to Protestant whites being a minority in the country and those who are so desperately trying to retain that power and majority. The rhetoric and messages these groups produce alienate others and cause these divisions. I believe that Americans do have a common ideal that ties into the freedom and pride that the U.S. has and thats what connects and unites us. Like discussed in the do-now, the U.S. has turned into a salad bowl where diverse people can coincide and still retain some/all of their original culture or religion. This is also why the Republican "Coalition of Restoration" is becoming outdated, as the "new face" of the United States needs a more transformative ideal like that of the Democrats.
ReplyDeleteSamira Torna P.3
To me, in the article it seems like the author is trying to say that a change in diversity is happening very fast and this alone will throw America through a complete 180, in a negative way, but I feel the growing diversity is actually really positive. With a change in population, and a decrease in majority until pretty soon there won't be a majority is really good I think. Maybe it's not related, but to bring up majority rule, having one majority group of a population seems to make a lot of decisions one sided in government. With the changes in population and not having a majority, I feel it will more accurately describe what the people of America want, instead of what just one large group wants. In the article it seems like the author feels that having an increase of diverse people who are all not just the same will throw America off, but I think that's ridiculous. I feel having a country without a majority and having a country of all kinds of people instead of just one group will allow for a better country that is more accepting and advanced.
ReplyDeleteWyatt Lemoine, period: 2
It’s clear to all of us that the US is changing, whether we like it or not. Not even 10 years ago there were still PSA’s against same-sex marriage but look at us now, its seen more as a norm than ever before. Not only that, as we learned in class today, whites are slowly but steadily losing the title of being the majority of the US’s population, and just as the article says, different religions are spreading as well. Becoming more diverse demographically and culturally isn’t the problem, the problem is that so many Americans can’t be bothered in their conservative bubble. They won’t embrace the fact that their country is changing. You go to states like Kentucky, Tennessee, Missouri, everyone is just surrounded by the same people with the same beliefs, they aren’t as exposed to diversity and change as us in California. In a single row in our classroom, everyone comes from a different background with a different story and different beliefs. In conservative states…I really doubt that’s the case. This lack of diversity is part of the problem of American’s not accepting change, they fear what they don’t understand or are familiar to. It’s a comfort zone that people are stuck in, preventing us from moving forward as a nation. I do think that at some point we will all be able to mix well together and create an almost perfect salad (there are always going to be people who don’t want change), with less pieces of lettuce that don’t have any dressing, but for now, people need to adapt and accept that change is coming, and it’s for the better.
ReplyDeleteErick Martinez p3
"Eroded those pillars of American identity over the last generation"? This is so ludicrous to me, the "American Identity" is an idea, and is different for everyone. My American identity is that I am a Pakistani American and live in California and have been extremely fortunate to grow up in an affluent area with opportunity and a quality education, someone else's identity is just as specific to them as mine is to me. Thats phrasing itself just confused me- to think that the "American identity" is one specific thing and now as society has grown and molded we have chipped away at it- that doesn't make sense! On the contrary, the diversification the friction the expansion of PEOPLE on America's palette, all of it only adds more and more pigment to the masterpiece! I disagree with the author's opinion on this, but at the end of the day I'm okay with that and I think that that's what it's about. I am okay to agree to disagree, I understand that maybe my opinion isn't engraved in everyone's mind. I think that that can be one of the hardest parts about people coming together as "one"- realizing that not having the same exact synapses and opinions as everyone around us is SO okay; furthermore, while some may see that as our most prominent divide, I think a facet of it can also be seen as our strength- understanding that being unified means accepting our disagreements as well as our agreements.
ReplyDeleteAmani Ali Period 2
Judging by the tone of the author, it seemed that he was describing the thriving rate of diversification as a negative thing. I think that people's views on diversity varies depending on where you live in the country. I think diversification is a necessity in this country to best tackle the remaining traces of racism and bigotry within our country and perhaps strengthen relations with other countries.
ReplyDeleteChristopher Jordan, P.3
I completely disagree with the author of this article. Diversification and change within our borders is crucial to our identity as a nation. Change will always happen. I think that the fact that America is rapidly becoming more diverse is great. Like discussed in today's lesson, in our lifetimes (perhaps) minorities will become the majority. While some people view this as bad, I think that we need to accept this change with open arms. The world is a place of constant change, whether we like it or not. We need to learn to accept the inevitable changes that are coming our way instead of fighting them. Even though America will become more diverse, we will all still retain the ideas on which this country was built on. Diversity is a beautiful thing. We are blessed to be studying in SoCal, where we can see a hijabi, a Latino from any Latin American nation, Africans from every part of Africa, and so so many more different people (all in one day, and one place! It's amazing!). Some states in the US don't experience that, so I feel like that is where the author of this article is coming from. Sometimes unfamiliarity is amazing for our development, and we need to learn to roll with the punches and come together as a nation that promotes diversity, as well as individual identity.
ReplyDeletePeriod 5
I disagree with the author of this article. With our country becoming more and more diverse the author views this as a problem. However I believe that this shows how strong people believe in what or country is about, freedom, liberty and opportunity. This is what still binds our country together and with our country becoming more and more diverse shows how strong people feel towards this. This diversification also expands the different cultures that we come into contact with which I believe benefits the individual.
ReplyDeleteI believe our national culture is not something we can easily define- heck, some people don't know who they really are before they reach mid life crises or are told straight away what kind of people they are. Striving to find the answer in the midst of people who are coming in is not the same as understanding their core values- which are most likely the same values pilgrims and immigrants from all different times and countries had at the time they came to America. In other words, a fresh start where they are free from discrimination, a land of opportunity, a place where they can feel safe. That's been America's mantra for years and years, no matter who is saying it, no matter what they look like, no matter what religion they practice; we all have these same core values. But the author's want to categorize and scrutinize and to define- Americans can't do that. Despite what other people may think, we are so interwoven and powered by each other that by categorizing, and stereotyping, we harm ourselves as opposed to heal- the ideals that immigrants from years ago had don't just belong to one race of people, it belongs to everyone who thinks in the same way-. There may be different ways to execute these ideals, yes. But most everyone in this country believes in the natural rights our forefathers put down even though they were written long ago. I, personally can only conclude that it doesn't make us all that different after all.
ReplyDeleteFrancesca Vista, Pd. 5
(okay just want to say sorry if my comment doesn’t make sense but I found it really hard to express what I wanted to say)…I personally don’t think that being a nation that is constantly evolving and full of diversity as a problem. I think that being open minded, our diversity and willingness to accept people for who they are is what sets us apart from any other nation. Change is always occurring, happens within everything and everyone, to stop change or limit the changes that happen in our nation is like taking one step forward, three steps back. We are truly are lucky to live in California where we are more divers and I think that every day we learn more and more of different cultures because of our friends but there is states that aren’t divers to the extent that we are and see these changes as a “problem” and that our nation isn’t “united”. I think that our generation must find a way to communicate and find common ground on our disagreements.
ReplyDelete-Jhosseline Urias Per.5
It's interesting to see that this vastly individualistic society that is America is suddenly afraid of the uniqueness of its people the moment these characteristics mainly derive from minority groups. Weren't we always a nation that celebrated the individual? Since when has that been a subject of concern?
ReplyDeleteFrom what I read, many of these cultural pendulum shifts are due to our progression as a nation demographically, educationally, and secularly... and it's okay to feel overwhelmed of the change; it's rapid and incessant and unpredictable. But I think that's the basis of American culture: change. We are an ever shedding, reptilian being whose blood temperature will change according to its surroundings and that's neither particularly good nor bad-- it's just how we are. And even if the temperature suddenly drops or rises and we find ourselves in dangerously unsettling environmental changes, we can always find a way to survive. I guess it's just a matter of will.
The melting pot of America-- where, in one we are many, but still one-- will always face obstacles... and these obstacles will always be different and more strenuous than the last... but I anticipate that we have the will and the want to get through it.
Sharon Park, P.5
I believe this growing diversity of people and religion should be looked at in a more positive light. We must remember that the founders of America themselves were in a way, immigrants. Therefore we should hold these new ideas that immigrants are bringing highly and assimilate them into a new “American culture”. I believe this nation has no definite identity rather one that changes with the generations. Although, with this change being brought about it is essential the former majority does not view this change as a threat in order for the nation to continue its success.
ReplyDeleteTariq Nugud P.3
The author, Ronald Brownstein, of this article gives many statistics on how the United States is becoming more diverse. Brownstein states that with more diversity, more changes to the government will occur and possibly change the US’s identity entirely. However, the United State’s identity has not changed. Our government was set on the fundamental principles of freedom and acceptance and adapts to what the people want. Throughout our government’s history, there have been many mistakes such as slavery and the absence of women rights, but were fixed to improve the nation as a whole. With more diversity comes the inevitable decrease in white majority in the US. It should not matter where the majority is. What matters is whether or not citizens are fighting for freedom and acceptance. Our identity as a nation is one of many cultures that work their best to protect freedom that we all enjoy.
ReplyDeleteJames Stock P. 3
I disagree with the author’s claim that we are “out of one, many.” Diversity isn’t destroying our nation, it’s only an evolution of what America was originally founded as nearly 200 years ago and a forecast of what the future of this nation holds. The author claims that, “…what unites America has always been greater than what divides us.” If what unites us is greater than what divides us, we, as a nation, will continue to see change that may be shocking and scary but it cannot infringe upon who we are because out of many, we are one.
ReplyDeleteJob Kimani
Period 2
I don't believe that just because our country is becoming demographically diverse means that we are separating as a country. Altercation of views on marriage and the increasing amount of colored population, for example, isn't a sign of a separating country but a uniting country: depicting that America is encountering more and more diversity every single day. And the fact that we can accept each other for who we are shows that we are growing stronger together as one nation. E unum pluribus doesn't mean that we all must subject or agree to any certain viewpoint, but to have the ability to have an open mind and embrace each other's differences.
ReplyDeleteGiuseppi Pelayo
Period 2
My first impression of the author’s view towards the growing diversity and “panorama of alternative experiences” was hostile, it seems as though he rejects any sort of change and fears it and its consequences. I disagree with the author because I believe that the more diverse a country is the more it has to offer. Yes, throughout the years minorities are becoming the majorities now and the once many are now becoming the few, and many people fear that because it feels like power is being taken away from them. This shouldn’t be the case, the demographic and cultural change has a positive outcome in our society. The diversity in cultures, religions, and ethnicities are the foundation of this country.
ReplyDeleteAdriana Ortiz
P.5
I believe that there will be a common culture and some sense in unity in the United States regardless of the changes occurring. I believe that our culture will remain unchanged. Our culture is built off immigration and it slowly takes in practices and ideas from other cultures and implements it into our own U.S culture. U.S culture is different between different locations of the U.S because of how large it is. In fact, I believe that the changes in the U.S are actually helping in creating a united culture, at least in areas of large diversity, because, and It might be far fetched to think this, but I believe that with the appearance of Trump as president has grown a culture of people disliking and criticizing his ideas and concepts. Right now, even in other countries, it is culture to just make fun of Trump. In effect, I think his non supportive attitude towards immigration is just helping the idea that, U.S culture is the culture of diversity and variation among its citizens, a country with no dominant race, no dominant skin color.
ReplyDeleteCedrych Ramiro P.2
I think it’s a beautiful thing that this country is becoming more diverse. This country was founded by immigrants and should continue to grow as a country filled with different cultures, religions, and perspectives. The author of this article stated that this country is moving toward “a society with no racial majority”. I don’t see the problem with this at all. If anything I believe this would only strengthen us as a country and make us all unite even more because nobody would be a majority and be seen as “better” or of higher importance. I think diversity is what unites us because the more normal it becomes for people to be surrounded by differing cultures and opinions the easier it becomes for people to interact with one another and understand each other. With diversity, there is room to take separate ideas and philosophies and combine them into something that can work toward the same goal and make this country better.
ReplyDeleteViviana Nunez P.5
I disagree with the authors claim that diversity is weakening our country. I feel the diversity of the nation is what makes us so great. I think the people who say it is a weakness, are scared that something somewhere down the line, their race will be the lesser dominant and therefore hold less "power". Through diversification of a nation, we see the many different cultures and religions one would not see with only being around those of the american cultures, so to speak. Yet, with those who are immigrants to this nation, we learn so much more about how the other side of the world may live in comparison to us and it should open our eyes more and our hearts to the diversification of the nation
ReplyDeleteJurnee Joseph p.2
DeleteI totally agree with the author that our diversification is dividing America, however it is our fault or letting that happen. People who imitate Trump by choosing to seperate people due to their differences is the main thing keeping us from accepting each and communicating with each other. If we accept our differences we can succeed in many more thing and help our country get stronger. I think it is to our advantage that diversity in America is increasing so that we can make our society stronger and better.
ReplyDeleteKaren Girgis p2
As I see it, diversity is never a bad thing until one group tries to reign above the rest. The author stated that the country is on a path for a future with no racial majority. America blossomed into what it is today because of the flow of immigrants from all over the world. The strong feeling of wanting equality for everyone even though cultures differ from one another is what keeps unity present. I think the author is just afraid that this obstacle may prove to be difficult for the US to overcome, but the past shows that we always prevail.
ReplyDeleteJeric Gaddi P 3
DeleteThe United States is known for being a safe haven for multiple cultures. Americans, both as individuals and as a civilization, are shaped and consumed by race and ethnicities. Moreover, race is an issue that continues to play a fundamental role in structuring and representing society. Race is a matter of both social structure and cultural representation. I believe racial diversity and different cultures are what makes the United States so great. Diversity can bring compassion and unity, as is evident when we see how people, from all different backgrounds, come together to stand up and fight for what they believe is right. Fighting for human rights is the commonality that continues to holds us all together. Our country has overcome several difficult challenges, and it will continue to be stronger than ever.
ReplyDeleteJuliann Salinas Period 2
In my opinion we will be able to stand the brunt change in our demographics. America will always be unified in their core values of freedom, justice, and individualism. I personally think that we can only get stronger from this immigration and that the key struggle will be in making sure minorities are properly represented with dignity, so as to preserve and humanize them in the face of blind xenophobia from an aging white generation. I believe that whether American unity fractures or consolidates will be determined by the opinions and sentiments of the last White dominated generation. By the look of our reactionary right and President Trump, America's current demographic transition might be off to a rocky start
ReplyDeleteJulian Gutierrez
Per. 2
I really do not feel that the motto "E Pluribus Unum" should be viewed as "E Unum Pluribus." Rather, the meaning we derive from the slogan could adapt to the times. Saying "out of many, one" now is symbolic of the fact that the US as a nation is made up of many different cultures that unite to form one ideology that the US stands for, for example its freedom of religion. Instead of assuming the saying is holding on to the founding principles of things like racism and slavery, allow it to morph to fit the core ideals the nation will always exhibit.
ReplyDeleteLainey Gerber
period 5
I do not agree with the author because I believe that diversity shouldn't be viewed negatively. This country is made up of people with different religions, ethnicities, sexual orientations, etc. We are exposed to new ideas and beliefs, which should be accepted. These changes will prove to be beneficial and strengthen our nation.
ReplyDeleteJessica Lee
Per.2
Brownstein recognizes that America is becoming more and more diverse and therefore we, as a nation, have become more separated due to our own beliefs. I somewhat agree to his reasoning that America has started to turn to “many” instead of “one” because of the growth of different cultures and views that others cannot agree upon. Our advancing and developing country has caused unheard of principles from perhaps the older generation. Thus, disconnection in the participation of varying groups to unite arises and creates disorder and lawlessness. On the other hand, I believe that America is altogether united because,throughout history, we have found a way to come to an agreement and as a result created a prosperous and thriving nation.
ReplyDeleteMikayla Teves Period 5
Although I think it is pretty noticeable based on the responses and the very demographics of our AP Gov class, that we share a common belief that diversification in our national demographics is a positive, and fast-moving change. I too agree with this statement and with much of the insights my fellow classmates have given through these comments. With this being said, I think it is important to note that the political upheaval that is currently going on, and arguably, is as a result of this rapid change in demographics, has been present throughout all of history. Through all of history, clashing political ideologies and factions have risen. But need we get upset and pout over the injustice present? Yes, the extent to which diversification has grown is astonishing, but instead we should bring up the masses of minorities, regardless of ethnicity, religion, socioeconomic level, etc., because after all the United States has been built upon the ideals of pluralism and the fact that since the creation of our nation, political equality is placed over economic equality--and we should use this to our advantage.
ReplyDeleteRebecca Covarrubias
period 5
One lasting thought this article left me thinking about was, what unites us as a country of many different people. My answer to that would be taking the honor and freedom that America gives to its citizens. This sense of knowing that many different people with a variety of backgrounds and cultures are all united in one country is what fuels America's motto of out of many one. The process of blending many into one isn't always perfect at times but America is one of the most greatest country's in the world for a reason. Being a citizen of America means that you can come from anywhere in the world and be accepted, which is what makes America great and upholds the saying out of many one, not out of one many.
ReplyDeleteKayla Scarberry p.2
I disagree with the author although I feel as if I am a bit biased. As a first-generation American with immigrant parents, it’s unnerving to see anyone claim that an influx of diversity is contributing to the U.S. in a negative way. I know the statement “America was founded by immigrants” is a common one when regarding immigration, but even if this wasn’t so, I still fail to see why people would see change in the demographic as a negative thing. The phrase “change is a good thing” was not coined for no reason and if anything, the changes that the U.S. is experiencing are only an example of the positive growth that we are making as a nation. The sudden “new” presences of different types of cultures, sexualities, races, religions, etc. only furthers this notion as it proves that these individuals and minorities feel comfortable enough to claim the things that make them different rather than hiding them or trying to “Americanize” themselves. With this being said, I don’t feel the need for a common culture to unite us as long as we can all learn to live in harmony with one another. I also believe that we will be able to absorb the culture shock as long as America tries and continues to protect all of its citizens and make them feel safe in their own skin, since no one will feel like targets, be it a Protestant White or a Muslim Asian. We can all come to a consensus that this nation is already great and being able to come together despite our differences is what makes us a strong nation, even stronger than before.
ReplyDeleteThe U.S. will be able to survive this cultural shock. The diversity of the nation has only grown stronger as time goes on and each time we have one of these shocks we end up stronger. There will always be backlash by people who fear change and those who often look back on the "good ol' days" as being perfect. We are expanding the rights of people to those who were previously discriminated against. This push back and forth is natural and in time the two sides will compromise just as the founders did to establish the Constitution.
ReplyDeleteNicolas Goodling
P.2
I think it's a very good thing that this country has been growing through the years. There is no longer a majority religion in this country, whites aren't as large of a majority as they used to be, and more people are getting educated at a college level. As you can see, several demographics have drastically changed from 1980 to now, and as the years are going by we are changing even more. I do agree with the statement "what unites America has always been greater than what divides us". Although our demographics may not all be similar, we still know how to unite as a country with all of our similarities and differences.
ReplyDeleteSitembile Sukuta, P. 5
I disagree with the writer of this article. Change is always scary, especially if it occurs at such a rapid rate;however, the different demographics that exist within the US should not be frowned upon. These differing religions,ethnic groups, and the evolution of ideologies have made America a stronger nation. It gives us more insight and knowledge about the world and can bring about novel ideas that can better the nation. America is a country that thousand of people fought for to attain and maintain liberty; it's also because of this that it's so diverse. Thousand of immigrants chosoe to come here to have a better life and create a better future for their children; not because they want to tear it apart. Many see this country as hope and a new beginning. Freedom and hope are the two major things that, in my opinion, hold thing country together.
ReplyDeletePatricia Molinos, period 5
I have to fully agree with Michael on his overall stance that we truly cannot predict the future regardless of our attempts to do so. Some may conclude, myself included, that demographical diversification, is present and in turn essential, as our great nation was built on these principles anyways. However others may retort that change doesn't connotate progression, and relay that stagnation is a surefire way to ensure a constant culture. Personally I believe it ultimately comes down to both perspective and understanding. A great majority of humans fear change and view it through a negative perspective, and the fact of the matter is that regardless of culture, each and every one of us has a distinct perspective to offer. As we move forward towards this new and rapid era of diversification it is solely up to us to attempt to understand the various cultures now surrounding us, and with that understanding develop respect. It is IMPOSSIBLE for such a great amount of people to mesh perfectly and act uniformly, even within their own respective cultures, as change occurs, but while moving forward if we make the effort to understand the change that is occurring around us and broaden our own perspectives, unity may not be far out of reach.
ReplyDeleteKenechi Ikeanyi (Period 5)
*My previous entry got accidentally deleted, but here's a simplified version of what I wrote:
ReplyDeleteThe author and I share the same sentiment in regards to the unification of the inestimable diversity of America: HARD. Every day, I beat myself up thinking about how ONE government is expected to accommodate the infinitely diversified interests of the American people. I honestly feel bad for Trump as I put myself in his shoes. I can't imagine trying to lead a country and getting scrutinized for every move I make. Every time he whispers a word, a thousand more people join a protest. Trying to make decisions in a country that is in "Democrat vs Republican", "Us Versus Them", smash-mouth mode makes me want to run into my bed and pull the blankets over. Today, the maps showing the populations densities of each ethnicity throughout the U.S expressed to me that minorities are not as assimilated as we BELIEVE they are. This is only one of the many social chasms America faces. Mix in the political and economical differences, and we have a divided, "United", States of America. So far this entry seems pessimistic, but I believe that a common struggle (Hopefully not another civil war), will bring the "many" together. Not until we can ask ourselves, "Why are we even arguing?" and realize that everyone has, or SHOULD have, the mutual interest of the greater good, will America unite. E Unum Pluribus.
Sebastian Arceo
P-5
I think that our nation is accelerating towards division, due to both reactionary conservatism and, ironically, the "tolerance" of the far-left.
ReplyDeleteSocially speaking, especially under the controversial Trump administration, America has become divided rapidly. The most recent presidential election was a stinging reminder of how regional politics have already become; urban areas and the coasts tend to be liberal, while rural areas tend to be conservative hotbeds. Couple this regionalism that harkens back to the similar geographical divisions of antebellum America with the "us vs 'libtards'" conservative mentality and the rise of hyperliberal college courses that preach acceptance and then castigate those with differing opinions as awful people filled with hate, and we have a recipe for social division. But I digress.
Changing demographics will most definitely be a fuel for social change. Liberalism and, in particular, conservatism will become more radical. Of course, the changing demographics will most likely be fueled by Hispanic and Asian immigrants, who already make up the bulk of current immigration. I think, as a whole, simply due to the current tendency for minorities to swing left and to the sheer numbers of non-white people in America, the States will experience a social shift to the left.
Will we keep our popular culture? In some ways, yes. I feel that we will keep our senses of civic duty, our unique ingrained religiosity, and our high esteem of the government. But I fear that the one core value that, as of now, unites us all the most strongly is threatened; patriotism has been and will be deeply tested as a unifying national value.
The 2016 elections and the effective of the motto "Make America Great Again" have shown that a massive amount of people feel doubtful about the state of the USA and their civic competence. Trump represents, to them, a chance to restore patriotism and civic competence.
Patriotism will also be tested by the inflow of immigrants. With our government willingly serving immigrants with multilingual publications that may deter new immigrants from learning English and assimilating, combined with immigrants' tendencies to self-segregate into ethnic communities, I feel that immigrants may feel more removed from the American values of patriotism. After all, an immigrant surrounded by government publications printed in his or her native language and living in Little Insert-Country-Name-Here or Country-Name-Here-Town is practically still in the country he or she emigrated from in the first place.
- Arthur Kim
- Period 5
in my opinion, the author is just babbling. we have always been a country of many different cultures united by one goal: freedom. the diversity in american culture is so wide that there is no stopping it. although even if we are united we are separated: by culture, race, religion, etc. but the thing is, it has made our country what it is today. change is hard, but as united as we already are, we can make it better by coming together as a bigger one than a divided two if that makes sense
ReplyDeleteThe United States has always been a nation of diversity. By the author saying that diversity is growing problem is an insult to the ideas that this nation established.
ReplyDeleteAndy Garcia P.2
The diversity of the United States is an experiment that has failed for all other countries. The U.S has a history of being aggressive to other groups like other nations. The genocide of Native Americans, to the removal of rights of minority groups to dehumanize them and prevent them from climbing the economic, political, and social ladder. The majority group of the United States has always tried to put down rising groups that would rival the groups dominance. Other countries have always had different groups fight each other for power whether they were religious, racial, or cultural groups. Most attacks have been extreme violence just as the U.S has had. The United States is no better than these other countries when it came to equality and peace between different groups. Local governments have always made it nearly impossible for minorities to further themselves in anyway. The United States will never survive because even when a new group becomes the majority they will not learn the history of their struggles and will assure their dominance over other groups.
ReplyDeleteEnrique Menjivar
P.3
My original comment was deleted.
The author seemed to have a negative opinion of the diversity that comes with immigration, but I belive that this change in culture isn't such a bad thing for the United States. As the the world progresses I think that Americans need to change their mindset and how they think and diversification does just this. Stating stagnant in a worl that is ever changing could potentially stop us from moving forward as nation in whole.
ReplyDeleteSeth Casas p. 5
The United States is in no way dividing but is growing to be more tolerant of others. But with that being said there still is some inequalities being shown today through ignorance. The U.S has always been a country found of changing and advancing, but to keep advancing the U.S can not diverge from its found principles ( equality to all) . As Chief Justice John Roberts said it best, “The court today not only overlooks our country's entire history and tradition but actively repudiates it, preferring to only live in the heady days of the here and now”. with his statement being said we can not say we will wait and deal with some problem in a decade or two but we have to deal with it here and now so the future we look for has the same principle as it all was had. In the end I would like to state that If the U.S every becomes divided, creating a second civil war it would be the media's fault. The reason being that if you use proper words to convey emotion of fear to the reader constantly you would find the true human nature showing up and causing the papules in taking sides.
ReplyDeleteImran jalal
Ps internet down yesterday
I feel that the phrase, "out of many- one," is the culture of the U.S., which is trying to embrace freedom and liberty, ultimately leading to change. The demographics are changing rapidly and substantially in the American population. It astonishes me that 1 out of every 4 Americans do not claim to have any religious affiliation. Contrary to some beliefs, I feel as though that is a main reason for America's decline in morality. I definitely feel that the minorities are affecting the Transformation Coalition's Core to make it stronger. The author claims that this Coalition appeals to the minorities, millennials, socially liberal, and the college educated whites (especially the women) who are comfortable with this racial and social transformation. I feel like we can get too far in letting humans choose based off of these impulsive passions or whims of beliefs, because not only has history proven human nature to be corrupt; but America should know better not to be controlled by personal desires because that is why our government is a republic. Seriously, political parties, I believe, are a loophole to get a majority's agenda accomplished. Another thing that astonishes me is that by 2040 there should be no majority race. That is incredible. That is something that we, as Americans, can not really control, but it is great. People are born the way they are born. This racial diversity creates a beautiful American culture of the same freedom to be true to oneself. Out of the many people, cultures, beliefs, views, and opinions, we find ourselves agreeing with some things and disagreeing with others. I have learned as a proud American how to understand people without accepting their beliefs, if I do not agree with them. I have that right; I have my freedoms of speech and religion (my beliefs). Once an American is forced to ACCEPT something they do not agree with, things get weird. "Out of many- one" culture does not form; instead "out of many- few" resentments form, which seems to be the case with the most controversial changes; gay marriage, transgender issues, abortions (health care), and many more.
ReplyDeleteI dont know if I have made a post on this before i believe I did but since I don't see it i guess I'll do this again.
ReplyDeleteThe author had a nasty/negative view on the affects of diversity due to immigration. See the truth is America is becoming more and more tolerant of all kinds of people on a daily. I for one don't believe anyone can predict the future of this country and with that said I also don't see any one or more states successfully leaving this nation without lots of bloodshed which no one wants to see so I truly don't believe any of this will happen.
Diante Lowe
P.3